Is the Employer Always Right?

In this new, chaotic, and uncertain century, with its more and more minutely specialized occupations and skill sets and with nothing to do with the faltering economy, it’s not only human resources employees who might not be familiar with certain job skills and the actual needs of the open positions in their organizations. Believe it or not, the hiring managers themselves many times don’t know their own needs until the hapless chosen candidate has completed a typically extensive, lengthy, complex, and personally probing on-boarding administrative process and the candidate has already started reporting for work. Then the employer suddenly dismisses the employee—after perhaps only one or two days on the job—saying it has decided the employee’s skills apparently don’t match the actual needs of the position. That reason is not an employer cover-up for dismissal for a different reason. It is indeed the actual reason.

We’re living in a fast-paced world. Not only in our personal and family lives is everyone in the household or among our acquaintances going in different directions, but the same phenomenon is prevalent even more at work. For instance, the economy forces senior management to make budget cuts, which then cascades down the chain of command. Sometimes management changes are made, and literally everyone gets asked to do more with less and in less time. It’s no wonder, then, that hiring decisions nowadays are going not through a reasonable-length process but through an accelerated, hasty process—one that brings its victims. Employers are treating staff like a printed circuit board in an electronic module: Plug it in, and let’s see whether it’s working. If it is found that the wrong part has been used, it gets quickly replaced with a new one. Perhaps the replacement part will work better.

It is a fact that high employee turnover is very costly and not only in dollars and cents. Does the employer regret or feel contrite that such a dismissal—not based on the employee’s fault—leaves an indelible scar on the psyche of the employee? The answer is, most likely not. And the painful part of that too-often occurrence is going to stay with us until the buyer’s market shifts to the seller’s market, the way it used to be in the late 1900s.

Many people in America lost their jobs because of a shift in the economy that was due to the transfer of a large part of manufacturing to countries where labor is less expensive. Another reason is that evolution of the technology whose machines and computers introduced efficiency made people or hands become redundant. And generally, people are slow in adjusting to the new world. For instance, today’s car mechanics need specialized computer skills and knowledge; otherwise, they cannot repair today’s highly computerized vehicles.

So, with these sorts of rapid changes here to stay, the only issue we’re left to grapple with is whether employers are always right. Do you know? Do you have an answer? What’s your opinion?

Picture of Alex Freund

Alex Freund

Alex Freund is a career and interviewing coach known as the “landing expert” for publishing his 80 page list of job-search networking groups. He is prominent in a number of job-search networking groups; makes frequent public presentations, he does workshops on resumes and LinkedIn, teaches a career development seminar and publishes his blog focused on job seekers. Alex worked at Fortune 100 companies headquarters managing many and large departments. He has extensive experience at interviewing people for jobs and is considered an expert in preparing people for interviews. Alex  is a Cornell University grad, lived on three continents and speaks five languages.

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

The thing I miss most about my parents isn’t their advice or their cooking or their house — it’s being someone’s child, having two people on earth whose job it was to worry about me, and when they died that role went with them and no one tells you that losing your parents in your sixties still makes you feel like an orphan no matter how old you are

The thing I miss most about my parents isn’t their advice or their cooking or their house — it’s being someone’s child, having two people on earth whose job it was to worry about me, and when they died that role went with them and no one tells you that losing your parents in your sixties still makes you feel like an orphan no matter how old you are

Global English Editing

I’m 65 and my daughter put me in a group chat with my grandchildren thinking it would help me feel connected and I’ve watched six hundred messages go by without anyone asking me a single question and the chat didn’t make me feel included — it gave me a front row seat to how easily the family moves without me

I’m 65 and my daughter put me in a group chat with my grandchildren thinking it would help me feel connected and I’ve watched six hundred messages go by without anyone asking me a single question and the chat didn’t make me feel included — it gave me a front row seat to how easily the family moves without me

Global English Editing

Quote by Carl Jung: “Loneliness does not come from having no people around you, but from being unable to communicate the things that seem important to you” — and boomers experience this specific type of existential isolation more than any other generation

Quote by Carl Jung: “Loneliness does not come from having no people around you, but from being unable to communicate the things that seem important to you” — and boomers experience this specific type of existential isolation more than any other generation

Global English Editing

I’m 73 and I overheard a woman at the pharmacy tell her friend “at least he has his health” about some man she knew and I wanted to tap her shoulder and say health without purpose is just a body with nowhere to send it and I would know because I’ve been healthy and useless for four years and no one has sent me a card for either

I’m 73 and I overheard a woman at the pharmacy tell her friend “at least he has his health” about some man she knew and I wanted to tap her shoulder and say health without purpose is just a body with nowhere to send it and I would know because I’ve been healthy and useless for four years and no one has sent me a card for either

Global English Editing

The rarest form of discipline isn’t the ability to push through discomfort – it’s the ability to stop doing something that’s no longer serving you even when everyone else expects you to keep going

The rarest form of discipline isn’t the ability to push through discomfort – it’s the ability to stop doing something that’s no longer serving you even when everyone else expects you to keep going

Global English Editing

People who raised their children to be independent and then got exactly what they asked for are experiencing the most underrated grief of the modern era — because the success of their parenting is measured by how completely their children don’t need them and nobody warned them that the reward for doing it right would feel identical to being left behind

People who raised their children to be independent and then got exactly what they asked for are experiencing the most underrated grief of the modern era — because the success of their parenting is measured by how completely their children don’t need them and nobody warned them that the reward for doing it right would feel identical to being left behind

Global English Editing