Caution: Giving Thanks Can Be Self-Defeating

Thanksgiving photo from ShutterstockIn the US, the upcoming national holiday is called Thanksgiving, which infers you should be thanking someone for something you valued. Thanks for what?

None of us are the original Pilgrims and very few of us are having dinner with Native Americans, who deserve a whole lot more than thanks. You may be sitting down to eat with your family and close friends or perhaps you are doing a pot luck with acquaintances or even having an HGTV marathon alone. I’m not sure it matters, except to say that I hope you’re doing what you want to do and eating what you want to eat.

In effect, most of us have morphed this holiday into a day off from work and discounted shopping.

I say this with some regret, because Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday. I love to cook the meal, decorate the house, and generally treat family and friends (and a few strays who have no where to go) to a festive day.  I have a ritual where I clean for a week, get the house organized and buy a few new things to spruce up the place.

In other words, Thanksgiving is a luxury for me. I focus intensely on something other than work and school.

So however it is you take this day, I hope it’s the same kind of joyful destination for you. In other words:

Let Thanksgiving be whatever YOU want it to mean.

I think a fixed day and time for gratitude may be dangerous. Similar to a day of religious confession, atonement or writing in your gratitude journal every morning: a forced ritual of emotional work can suck the meaning out of your life.

The scientific literature now shows that being grateful lowers your blood pressure and is a good stress reliever. So, certainly I don’t recommend against feeling grateful. style=”text-decoration: underline;”>Gratitude is a great way to reframe negative experiences>. It’s a way of getting over trauma. Gratitude gives you a way to acknowledge and leverage what happened in a positive way, since you learned a lot from a bad experience. But you don’t want to try to feel grateful before you have digested what happened and expressed how you felt about it.

Do be careful about manufacturing gratitude in the face of bad circumstances or to people who aren’t really rooting for you. Be sensitive to your true feelings and express them. Then, you may genuinely feel like you have want to express gratitude for the learning or growth you have experienced, and the people who really helped you.

And, when you are ready to be grateful and give thanks: make sure to include yourself at the very top of the list. You have been there for you all along.

Have a great day doing what you want to do: eat, sleep, binge watch or indulge in a favorite book or hobby. I’ll be doing the day my way, and thanking the people who help clean up!

Picture of Nance Rosen

Nance Rosen

Nance Rosen is the author of Speak Up! & Succeed. She speaks to business audiences around the world and is a resource for press, including print, broadcast and online journalists and bloggers covering social media and careers.

TRENDING AROUND THE WEB

Psychology says people who can’t eat without a screen aren’t undisciplined — they’ve trained their brain to treat silence as discomfort and stimulation as relief, and after enough repetitions of that pairing the screen stops being a choice and starts being a condition

Psychology says people who can’t eat without a screen aren’t undisciplined — they’ve trained their brain to treat silence as discomfort and stimulation as relief, and after enough repetitions of that pairing the screen stops being a choice and starts being a condition

Global English Editing

I was a military kid and the thing nobody asks about is not the moving or the absent parent or the instability — it is what happens to a child who is told, by the entire culture they are raised in, that their disruption is service, their loneliness is patriotism, and their losses are something to be proud of, and who believes it completely until they are old enough to wonder who exactly that story was serving

I was a military kid and the thing nobody asks about is not the moving or the absent parent or the instability — it is what happens to a child who is told, by the entire culture they are raised in, that their disruption is service, their loneliness is patriotism, and their losses are something to be proud of, and who believes it completely until they are old enough to wonder who exactly that story was serving

Global English Editing

Psychology says the men who carry the most regret into their 70s aren’t the ones who made the worst decisions — they’re the ones who made every decision from behind an ego that couldn’t tolerate being wrong, and spent so many years defending those decisions that they never had a quiet moment to honestly examine whether any of them had actually been right

Psychology says the men who carry the most regret into their 70s aren’t the ones who made the worst decisions — they’re the ones who made every decision from behind an ego that couldn’t tolerate being wrong, and spent so many years defending those decisions that they never had a quiet moment to honestly examine whether any of them had actually been right

Global English Editing

I grew up in a household where strength was the only acceptable response to anything — where crying was managed, fear was private, and difficulty was something you processed alone and quickly — and I built a very functional adult life on that foundation and a very lonely one, and I am still working out which of those two facts is more important

I grew up in a household where strength was the only acceptable response to anything — where crying was managed, fear was private, and difficulty was something you processed alone and quickly — and I built a very functional adult life on that foundation and a very lonely one, and I am still working out which of those two facts is more important

Global English Editing

8 quiet things someone does at a buffet that reveal whether they grew up in a household of scarcity or abundance — and the most telling one is what they do after they’ve already served a full plate

8 quiet things someone does at a buffet that reveal whether they grew up in a household of scarcity or abundance — and the most telling one is what they do after they’ve already served a full plate

The Vessel

Psychology says if you’ve ever walked into a room and immediately sensed that something was wrong before anyone said a word, your nervous system is operating on a detection frequency that was almost certainly shaped by your earliest environment

Psychology says if you’ve ever walked into a room and immediately sensed that something was wrong before anyone said a word, your nervous system is operating on a detection frequency that was almost certainly shaped by your earliest environment

Global English Editing